Questions to Ask a Divorce Lawyer in a Consultation

The questions to ask a divorce lawyer fall into three groups: how they read your case, who will actually do the work, and exactly how you will be billed. Most people spend the hour on the first group and almost none of it on the other two, which is backwards, because the second two determine what the next two years cost you and how much of your own time the case eats.

  • How they read your case. What it tells you: Whether they have handled one like yours. Time most people give it: Almost all of it.

  • Who does the work. What it tells you: Whether you get the person you are hiring. Time most people give it: Almost none.

  • How you are billed. What it tells you: What the case will actually cost. Time most people give it: Almost none.

What are the top 10 questions to ask a divorce lawyer?

Ten that cover all three groups, in the order worth asking them.

  1. How many cases like mine have you handled in the last two years?

  2. What is your read on the hardest part of my situation?

  3. Who will do the day-to-day work, and will I meet them today?

  4. What is your hourly rate, and theirs, and the paralegal's?

  5. What retainer do you need, and what happens when it runs down?

  6. What is your minimum billing increment?

  7. Are emails and phone calls billed, and at what rate?

  8. What would you expect this to cost if it settles, and if it goes to hearing?

  9. What do you need from me to keep costs down?

  10. How will you communicate with me, and how quickly?

Questions 4 to 7 are the ones almost nobody asks, and they are the ones that determine the bill. They are also the questions to ask divorce attorney candidates that will differentiate two firms that sound identical on everything else.

The single most useful reframe I can give anyone before a consultation is that you are conducting the interview, not sitting one. People arrive feeling they have to explain themselves well enough to be taken on, and they spend the hour proving their marriage was difficult. The lawyer already believes that. What you cannot find out later, and can find out in that hour, is how this person thinks and how they run a file.

How do you read the answers?

By listening for specificity, because a weak answer is almost always a general one.

  • Cases like mine. A strong answer: A number, and what was hard about them. A weak answer: "We handle a lot of those"

  • The hardest part. A strong answer: Names something you had not raised. A weak answer: Repeats your own summary back.

  • Who does the work. A strong answer: A name, a rate, and an introduction. A weak answer: "My team"

  • What it will cost. A strong answer: A range with the assumptions stated. A weak answer: "It depends on your spouse"

  • Keeping costs down. A strong answer: Concrete instructions for you. A weak answer: "We are very efficient"

"It depends on the other side" is true and it is also the answer that lets nobody estimate anything. Press once: ask what it costs if the case settles at mediation, and what it costs if it goes to a contested hearing. Any experienced attorney can give you two numbers.

Here is a thing I would watch for that nobody tells you. A lawyer who agrees with everything you say in the first hour is not necessarily on your side. In a high conflict case you want someone who will tell you, early and plainly, which parts of your position will not survive. The ones who do that in the consultation tend to be the ones who do not let a client spend four thousand dollars on a motion that was never going to land.

Which questions for divorce attorney fees actually matter?

The ones about how the meter runs, rather than the ones about the headline rate.

Questions to ask a divorce attorney during consultation about billing

Ask what the minimum billing increment is. Six minutes is common, which means a two-minute phone call is billed as six, and five short emails in a day can cost most of an hour. Ask whether emails and texts are billed and at what rate, whether a paralegal can answer routine questions more cheaply, and what the retainer covers. Ask what happens when the retainer runs down, how much notice you get, and whether work stops.

Things to ask a divorce lawyer that nobody thinks of

Then ask the question people leave out entirely: what can I do to reduce the bill? Most attorneys have a real answer, usually about batching questions, sending organised documents rather than piles, and not forwarding every message from the other side.

In my experience most of a retainer is not spent in court. It is spent on email. A client who sends eleven separate messages in a week has bought an hour of somebody's time at a litigation rate to receive information that could have gone in one message on Friday. That is the client's to control, and almost nobody realises it until the first invoice. If you do one thing with this list, ask question 9 and write the answer down. why a high conflict divorce costs more sets out where the rest of the money goes.

Questions to ask divorce attorney candidates, working through a list in a consultation

What should you bring to the consultation?

A one-page summary, a document list and your questions, which together turn an hour of explanation into an hour of advice.

Bring your own credit report too, which is free and which the Federal Trade Commission confirms you can only get from AnnualCreditReport.com. The summary is names, dates of marriage and separation, children's ages, and the three things you most want to know. The document list is what exists rather than the documents themselves: accounts, approximate balances, property, debts. Colorado requires both parties to exchange full financial disclosures and file a Sworn Financial Statement within 42 days of service under Rule 16.2, so you will be assembling this anyway. The Colorado Judicial Branch forms page shows what the Sworn Financial Statement asks for, and skimming it before the meeting will tell you what you do not yet know.

What is the biggest mistake during a divorce?

Hiring the most aggressive lawyer you can find because the other side has been aggressive.

It feels like matching force. What it usually buys is a case that escalates on both sides, because two attorneys briefed to fight will find things to fight about. In a genuinely high conflict case you want someone who is unflappable rather than combative, who documents carefully, and who does not take the bait. Escalation is the one thing that reliably makes these cases worse, as what a high conflict person actually is explains.

The second mistake is hiring on the first consultation because the conversation felt reassuring. See two, and put the same questions to ask a divorce lawyer to both. The difference between the two interviews tells you more than either one alone.

Do you need a lawyer and a coach, or just a lawyer?

A lawyer gives you legal advice and a coach does not, which is the whole distinction and the reason the two jobs do not overlap.

Your attorney is the expensive resource. A great deal of what people take to a lawyer is not a legal question: how to answer a message, whether to respond at all, how to prepare for an interview, what to do about a handover that keeps going wrong. The line between the two jobs is drawn in what a divorce coach does. Preparing for the consultation itself is one of the things a single session is most useful for.

If there is abuse in your situation, say so in the consultation rather than saving it, because it changes the advice. The National Domestic Violence Hotline is free and open 24 hours a day on 1-800-799-7233, with chat on their site or text START to 88788.

This describes how consultations generally work. It is not legal advice about your case.

Frequently asked questions

Next
Next

No Fault Divorce When Your Spouse Behaved Badly