The grey rock method is simple to explain and hard to do. You make yourself boring. Short, flat and factual. You stop supplying the reaction the other person is fishing for, and eventually the fishing stops.
With a co-parent it is harder, because you cannot simply go quiet. There are pickups to arrange, appointments to confirm and a child in the middle of all of it.
So I asked practitioners who work with high conflict separations how they actually teach it. Seven answered. Their answers are below, in their own words.
You will also see this written as the gray rock method. Same technique, two spellings.
How Practitioners Teach the Grey Rock Method
Keep Messages Strictly Logistical
Use a Parenting Communication App
Limit Details Beyond Child Needs
Defuse Provocations With Brevity
Repeat a Consistent Script
Reply With Calm Practical Facts
Schedule Responses for Nonurgent Issues
Keep Messages Strictly Logistical
Try the ‘logistics only’ rule. Every message to your co-parent covers just the who, what, when, and where: ‘Pickup is Friday at 5. Can you confirm?’ No commentary, no defending yourself. If they bring up something emotional, go right back to logistics.
It works best with a co-parent who likes to stir up conflict, especially over text, where you have time to edit before you hit send.
The biggest mistake is going grey rock in front of the kids. Kids feel that coldness as tension. Be boring with your ex, but stay warm with your children.
Dr. Lisa Palmer LMFT, PhD, CHT, CRRTTPsychotherapist & Trauma Expert, The Renew Center of Florida & RenewMeUse a Parenting Communication App
My favorite tool for supporting the grey rock method with a co-parent you must stay in contact with is a co-parenting app. Build it into your parenting plan with a phrase like: “All communication about the kids will occur within the communication app.”
Starting this way from day one creates transparency and accountability. The app timestamps and documents every message, and courts accept those records as evidence when needed.
When your co-parent tries to pull you into an argument, point back to the app. Say something like: “We already agreed pick up time is (x), in the app, remember?” or “Let’s discuss it in the app.” This boundary protects your well-being and keeps the kids out of the messenger role.
The strongest move is to set up the app as your primary communication method from the very beginning. With patience and practice, it saves you many potentially triggering conversations. Planning ahead serves you well.
Maura McMahonNarcissistic Divorce Recovery Coach, We Are The MothersLimit Details Beyond Child Needs
One practical way to use the grey rock method with someone you are coparenting with is only share the necessary facts about the children’s activities and whereabouts (as pertaining to the parenting plan requirements), but to be as vague as possible about anything over and above that information (i.e., what you are doing or where you are going, with whom, and when, etc.)
Schooling your features and curbing body language cues will also give your ex-partner less information, so they do not know how you’re feeling by an aggravated purse of your mouth, a defiant cross of your arms, or widened eyes that give them satisfaction in knowing they have shocked or hurt you.
The biggest hurdle in this technique, particularly with someone you’ve been intimately acquainted with on a romantic basis, is the lack of boundaries that likely was present when you were together. The tendency to appease, to try to reduce the negative consequences you were afraid of the other doing, to smooth over using soothing tones, all leads to oversharing on the whole, which provides the narcissist with ammo to use against you every time. So learning to shorten your responses, like you are talking to a judge in a courtroom who only wants you to answer the question posed, will help overcome this tendency. Anything more than a few words is likely too much.
Jeannie CampbellLicensed Marriage and Family Therapist, Hope Mountain CounselingDefuse Provocations With Brevity
I’m a Licensed Couples Therapist who specializes in Relationship Coaching. I am also a divorce mediator. High conflict marriages that end in divorce often continue as high-conflict co-parenting.
Grey rocking is a useful skill when dealing with a narcissistic or manipulative co-parent. The goal is NOT to avoid the other parent, but to remain emotionally neutral. I give my clients tactics that work well when they are doing drop-offs, pick-ups or attending children’s activities together. Some strategies are:
- Always remain calm. Never allow yourself to get escalated or hooked into an argument or disagreement. Pause before responding, talk more slowly and quietly than you normally do.
- Be brief. Don’t explain yourself, justify, or defend yourself from personal attacks. Less is best!
- Stay focused on the children. Keep to their schedule, activities, schooling matters and medical needs. Never bring yourself into it. Never talk about what is best or most convenient for YOU.
Examples:
- If your Ex tries to engage in a long emotional or angry text, simply repeat a short sentence that stays on point like, “I will pick the kids up after soccer practice at 5pm on Tuesday”.
- If your Ex tries to be critical of you or your parenting, don’t take the bait and defend, simply say, “I understand you have a different opinion.” Then, leave it.
- If your Ex tries to detain you, provoke you or escalate, say something like “I hope you have a good evening, I need to get going.”
Big mistakes people make:
- Answering every accusation.
- Trying to prove you are the most right.
- Getting hooked into an argument.
Gina GuddatLicensed Psychotherapist and Relationship Expert, Gina Guddat CounselingRepeat a Consistent Script
The grey rock method is a very effective way to manage difficult conversations with a volatile person, but it takes some practice. I encourage my clients to embody being a broken record of the most boring song they’ve ever heard. Whatever you can say that’s factual, neutral, and most importantly consistent will eventually neutralize the other party’s engagement. It can work well in any situation: logistics, parenting decisions, and more.
People get tripped up trying to use this method when they can’t resist the bait, a partner trying to engage by getting someone to justify, defend, or explain their decisions or behavior. Becoming comfortable with not trying to convince, persuade, or “get someone to understand” and allowing for differences is a key.
Jennifer Petty LMHCTherapist/Owner, Seattle Counseling CenterReply With Calm Practical Facts
We have a choice in how we decide to communicate with other people. We can either choose to add petrol to a fire or we can decide to dampen it down.
If we receive a message that’s critical of us as a person or as a parent, amongst the practicalities of co-parenting, it can be really easy to defend ourselves or reflect the criticism back at the other parent and point out their own imperfections. We end up in a situation that we’ve been in many times before, where a text argument takes place and overwhelms us.
It’s much better if we can stick to the practicalities and not get drawn into the conflict. If we ask ourselves what the impact has been of trying to ‘win’ an argument, it’s probably likely that we’ve caused ourselves some upset that we didn’t need.
Keeping things civil protects us, but more importantly, it protects our kids from being stuck in the middle. It’s very hard to stop the overspill of even a quiet argument over text from impacting other aspects of our lives.
Reply with facts. “I will be there at 4:30.” It’s okay to apologise for being late previously if that’s what happened. By all means, say “Have a good weekend.” Keep it civil and minimal, without getting drawn into another argument. You don’t need to be cold. Just know your own boundaries around what you need and don’t need to say.
You’re taking responsibility for your part as a parent. You’re just choosing not to allow things to escalate. Your kids need you to get along to a point, for their benefit, as you will need to be in contact with each other for years to come. Maybe even as your kids become adults, you will need to be in the same space as each other.
Gareth WallDad Coach, Be A Super DadSchedule Responses for Nonurgent Issues
Waiting an arbitrary 24 hours for every message can create problems when a deadline, pickup change, or child-related concern needs a prompt response. I recommend using a scheduled response window for nonurgent messages to identify the child-related decision required and respond briefly and factually.
Observing one’s feelings is key to managing reaction or response. We often react in ways that are not in tune with our values when emotions are running high, so we need to consciously decide, in advance, how we want to respond in stressful situations.
Whether the communication is through a phone call, email, or text message, communication does need to happen on a regular basis between co-parents. Be consistent in communicating with your co-parent about your children and schedule changes.
The silent treatment should not be confused with taking time to cool down after heated or difficult exchange. Silence can feel like a dignified, high road response but ignoring necessary child-related communication can create problems. A delayed reply alone is not necessarily the silent treatment, but repeatedly ignoring important messages can be. Still, there’s only an extent to which you can apply gray rocking in toxic situations. If you are in immediate physical danger get help whether you have started gray rock or not.
Dr. Dakari Quimby MA, PhDClinical Advisor, Marietta SpringsUsing the Grey Rock Method Without Overusing It
Across all seven answers, grey rocking is described as a tool for particular exchanges. It is not a personality to adopt and it is not the silent treatment.
It is short. It is factual. It stays on the child. It does not explain, defend, or try to win. And it stops at the front door, because the one thing the practitioners above warn about most is going grey rock in front of your children. Be boring with your ex and stay warm with your kids.
Expect it to feel wrong at first. Expect the other parent to push harder for a while once the reaction they are used to stops arriving. That part is usually a sign the method is working, not a sign it has failed.
If the messages are already out of hand, a structured plan for handling them is the sort of thing we build in one on one coaching.
If you are in immediate danger, call 911. The National Domestic Violence Hotline is 1-800-799-7233, free and confidential, 24 hours a day.
Related Reading
Frequently asked questions
-
It is a way of responding that gives the other person nothing to work with. You keep replies short, flat and factual, and you leave out opinion, emotion and justification. The name comes from the idea of being about as interesting as a grey rock. It is used with people who escalate when they get a reaction.
-
It means becoming boring on purpose. You answer in short, flat, factual sentences and give nothing to react to. No defending, no explaining, no emotion in the reply. The aim is not to punish the other person or cut them off. It is to stop supplying the reaction they are looking for.
-
It is a tool for specific exchanges, not a way to live. Used with a co-parent who stirs up conflict it protects your time and your nervous system. Used everywhere, or used in front of your children, it reads as coldness. Be boring with your ex and stay warm with your kids.
-
Grey rocking still answers. You reply to the child related question briefly and factually, then stop. Stonewalling ignores the message altogether. Taking an hour to cool down before replying is fine. Repeatedly leaving necessary messages about your children unanswered is not.
-
It works best in writing, where you can edit before you send. It works least well if you answer every accusation or try to prove you are right. Expect it to take practice, and expect the other parent to push harder at first when the reaction they are used to stops arriving.